*** Guided by Voices
DO THE COLLAPSE
(TVT)
Half the kick of seeing
Guided by Voices is watching former-grade-school-teacher-turned-rock-and-roll
savior Robert Pollard make like Roger Daltrey with the mike cord and Jackie
Chan with his feet. The rest comes from hearing all those hissy, home-recorded
nuggets that Pollard and his Dayton pals have been four-tracking for the past
20 years recast as proud-to-be-loud rock tunes. So anyone familiar with the
stage version of GBV won't be entirely surprised by the big rock production of
Do the Collapse, the first full-on studio recording by the "band," who
now count Pollard as the only founding member with former Cobra Verde guitarist
Doug Gillard, ex-Breeder drummer Jim MacPherson, and former Amp/Breeder bassist
Nate Farley. And now that you know Ric Ocasek produced the disc, there's no
reason to be blindsided by the Cars-y synths that pop up on the opening number.
The prolific Pollard and his extended GBV family (including Tobin Sprout)
have, under various guises, been flooding the market with their clever brand of
homemade guitar pop ever since Bee Thousand turned their little drinking
game into the hottest oddity to come out of Ohio since Pere Ubu's
Datapanik -- and for those of you who prefer the old, unpolished GBV to
the slick new one, there's Pollard's amusing new Lexo and the Leapers release
Ask Them: #2 in the Fading Captain Series (Rockathon). So from a
marketing perspective, a new band, label, and studio approach make a lot of
sense. The results sound, well, a lot more like Oasis than most indie
enthusiasts would probably like to admit. And that's not a bad thing at all.
But it's hard not to come away with the sense that, as well as GBV's songs hold
up to Ocasek's polishing, the time for Pollard to become the rock star he'd
like to be has come and gone.
-- Matt Ashare
|