***1/2 Mary Chapin Carpenter
PARTY DOLL AND OTHER FAVORITES
(Columbia)
If Mary Chapin Carpenter had never gone to Nashville, she'd be a
better-than-average New England folkie writing sensitive relationship songs.
But she learned to wrap her lyrical smarts around the country-singles formula
-- in short, she went commercial, and her music is the better for it. The best
of her singles -- "I Feel Lucky," "The Hard Way," "I Take My Chances" -- are as
literate as they are radio-friendly, and it's a pleasure to hear from grown-up,
respectable characters who like to drink and mess around now and then.
This compilation might be considered a one-disc boxed set, fleshing out the
hits with live tracks and rarities, including the title track, which is a
surprisingly effective remake from one of Mick Jagger's failed solo albums. Her
breakthrough hit is one of her few missteps: Lucinda Williams's "Passionate
Kisses" needs more sensuality than she gives it. But Carpenter reached a
creative peak with 1995's existential break-up album, Stones in the
Road, and that sensibility is maintained with the new original, "Almost
Home" -- whose key line ("There's no such thing as no regrets, but baby it's
alright") is about as double-edged as they come.
-- Brett Milano
|