*** Natacha Atlas
GEDIDA
(Mantra/Beggars Banquet)
Someday, perhaps,
the lady's handlers in Transglobal Underground will again release an entire
Atlas CD as eloquent as Diaspora. On her third album, however, as on
last year's Halim, one needs accept a whole lot of songs Arabicized and
trip-hopped in search of the one or two that allow Atlas to be what she really
is: the decade's lushest and most persuasive singer of exotic, romantic dream
pop.
On Halim, that song was "Agib," the last of 12 tracks. This time the
high drama comes first: her version of Françoise Hardy's "Mon amie la
rose" -- in which Atlas's olive-garden French meets the most fragrantly Arabic
shaabi beat imaginable, expressing all the grace in Hardy's lyric of
love and death, the short-lived intensity of the first leading to the
unrequited sad permanence of the second. Atlas touches the ecstatic summit, but
though Gedida offers other moments of symphony-and-Cairo-talk elevation
-- "Bahlam," "Ezzay," "The Righteous Path," and especially "Bastet" (a clever
blend of shaabi and rap) -- none reaches the heights of "Mon amie."
Gedida is less disfigured by tricked-up rhythms and costume-drama
Arabism than Halim, but too much of it lacks the fragile music and vocal
vulnerability that made Diaspora an album to love.
-- Michael Freedberg
|