*** Bonfire Madigan
. . . FROM THE BURNPILE
(Villa Villakula/Kill Rock Stars)
Madigan Shive is a baroque folk-punk diva who
loves clashing tone with mood. Her deep, strong voice is soulful when she's
wrathful and sexy when she's standoffish. And she plays a mean cello to
boot.
On her second album, . . . from the Burnpile, she's
joined by bass, lead guitar, drums, and on a couple of tunes a turntable DJ.
(The "Bonfire" is there to distinguish this from her solo work.) Her best songs
are either catchy or skronky, but when she trades her cello for a guitar, the
results can be gratingly sentimental. She's much more fun (and intimidating)
when she's incendiary, spouting likes like "Over my dead body/You'll touch me
or her," on "Anthemic Amendments." This song should come off as an annoying
diatribe, but its hip-hop groove and warm, humming cello make it appealingly
funky. On "Snowfell Summer" the moaning cello gives way to prancing pop as she
offers comment on our times: "Well-fed, we're apathetic." And she does a better
job than most of her post-riot-grrrl contemporaries at nailing down the
connection between love and protest with the song "Smoke Signals from the
Burnpile," where she serenades a lover with the lines "You are my Joan of
Arc/You are my Rosa Parks."
-- Joshua Westlund